The fraternity war

‘Gentlemen and scholars’

Original Chi Psi fraternity logo at U-M

The original Chi Psi logo. (Image: U-M’s Bentley Historical Library.)

In the fall term of 1845, just four years after classes had begun at the University of Michigan, a junior named George Becker and several friends joined together to create the University’s first fraternity, a chapter of Beta Theta Pi.

In their inaugural meeting, held in the Ann Arbor home of George’s parents, Hiram and Sophia Becker, they pledged upon their honor “as gentlemen and scholars to promote the best interests and welfare of all concerned, individually and collectively, in all the events of life, with friendship and fidelity, as far as may be consistent with the true principles of morality and duty.”

In December, 14 more students formed a chapter of Chi Psi. In August of the following year, 1846, a chapter of Alpha Delta Phi, with six members, joined the first two. (Betas and Chi Psis have quibbled ever since about which chapter deserves to be called Michigan’s first.)

Now something close to half the student body — all male in that era — belonged to one fraternity or another. But each society held its meetings in secret. For as they all knew, they were breaking Rule 20 of the University’s code of student conduct, one of 23 regulations that governed virtually every hour of their lives.

Life by the rules

The rules had been written by George Palmer Williams, the first professor hired by the regents, a favorite of students for his “genial, kindly nature” and “trenchant wit” in the classroom. But as the University’s catalog put it, “no college in our country can secure public confidence without watching over the morals of its students.” So professors governed the little campus in loco parentis — “in the place of parents.” Most of them were ordained Protestant ministers, and they were strict parents indeed.

Students took their meals with local families and slept in dorm rooms on the upper floors of the two academic buildings, Mason Hall and South Hall. The rules said they must rise to the janitor’s bell at 5:30 or 6 a.m. (depending on which half of the semester it was) and go straight to morning prayer. Then, on a typical day, they alternated between recitation periods in the classrooms and mandatory study periods in their own rooms. On a typical day, they studied from morning prayer until 7 a.m., 9 a.m. to noon, 1:30 p.m. to 4:30, and 7 p.m. to 9, after which no student was to leave the campus. “The student’s life, especially in the winter, is a life in a circle,” wrote George Washington Pray, a member of the first class. “He eats and studies and recites, recites and studies and eats.”

Rule 10 required each student to attend the local church of his choice twice each Sunday. Rule 14 forbade students to go home without a parent’s written authorization. Rule 19 required students to open their rooms to professors’ inspection “at all times.”

Then there was Rule 20, a minor matter: “No student shall become a member of any society connected with the University, or consisting of students thereof, which has not first submitted its constitution to the Faculty, and received approbation.”

Here Professor Williams was thinking only of student literary societies. The faculty approved of them, but didn’t want there to be too many.

They had no idea how much trouble Rule 20 would cause.

Cabin in the Black Forest

The Chi Psi Lodge in 1900

Chi Psi Lodge on campus, circa 1900. (Image: U-M’s Bentley Historical Library.)

Clearly, the faculty’s tight leash encouraged the forming of fraternities. At the Beckers’ home, or at a local hotel or tavern, Greek-letter brothers could escape for an hour now and then to smoke a pipe and commiserate away from professors’ eyes and ears.

The simple chance to make a few close friends — not provided for in the faculty’s tight schedule — was the main draw. In the grandiloquent style of the day, a Beta from Ohio said “the cultivation of intimate social relations” was “the leading motive of uniting a few choice spirits in closer bonds.”

The members of Chi Psi even built a cabin of their own east of the campus, deep in what they called the Black Forest. (The cabin’s exact site, lost to history, was probably in the acreage now occupied by Forest Hill Cemetery. Chi Psi still celebrates it as the first fraternity house in the U.S.)

They all knew they were breaking Rule 20, and they knew exposure could bring grave consequences. Secrecy and danger intensified the bond. As the Betas’ charter said, they kept it “ever…in mind that gold tried seven times in the fire is therefore more pure.”

The secret held for about a year.

Demands and defiance

Portrait of Andrew Ten Brook

Andrew Ten Brook discovered the existence of U-M fraternities when he overhead student boarders discussing their plans in his house. (Image: U-M’s Bentley Historical Library.)

To supplement his skimpy salary, Andrew Ten Brook, a sour-faced Dutchman who taught moral and intellectual philosophy, fed a few student boarders in his home. One night in 1846, he overheard a couple of the boys whispering about some late-night fires that had left neighboring farmers’ fences in smoldering ruins.

There was no dean of students to whom Ten Brook could report the matter. In fact, the University had no central administration at all. The board of regents held the purse-strings and set policy, but they delegated in loco parentis to the faculty. Each year, on a rotating basis, one professor was saddled with the title of chancellor, but that only made him first in a band of equals, with no special authority or power.

Nonetheless, that’s who Andrew Ten Brook told what he’d heard — the chancellor for 1846-47, Daniel D. Whedon, professor of logic, rhetoric and history.

They decided they had to investigate. When they saw a couple of students sneak away from the campus after hours, the professors shadowed them into the Black Forest. Unaware of their pursuers, the young men led them to the log cabin that was Chi Psi’s secret headquarters.

The professors demanded to be allowed inside.

The students refused.

They were members of a private society, they declared, and the faculty had no rights there.

In the back-and-forth that ensued, the students conceded the truth but remained defiant. Not only had they formed an association that broke Rule 20, they said, but so had two other societies at Michigan, and all three were affiliates of national organizations.

Years later, Professor Ten Brook remembered the students’ scoffing confidence in the woods that night, how they warned the professors that “their strength had become such as to make it difficult to deal with them.”

Continue reading at The Heritage Project. Pick up the story at Chapter 5, “Our Crazy Faculty.” 

Sources include: “Code of rules and regulations for the government of the University of Michigan, adopted by the Board of Regents, July 19, 1848,” “Special Report of Faculty on College Difficulties…,” January meeting, 1850, Proceedings of the Board of Regents (1837-1864); Kim Clarke, “The First Freshmen,” University of Michigan Heritage Project; Shelby Schurtz, Greek Letter Fraternities at the University of Michigan, 1845-1937 (1937); Andrew Ten Brook, American State Universities (1875); Phyllis S. Vine, “Nineteenth-Century Campus Crisis: The ‘Fraternity War’ at the University of Michigan, 1850” (student paper, 1970, Bentley Historical Library); Elizabeth M. Farrand, History of the University of Michigan (1885); and Burke A. Hinsdale, History of the University of Michigan (1906).


  1. Brian Heil - 1980

    You may wish to correct your article.

    Chi Psi preceded Beta Theta Pi at the University.

    This has been a long standing feud but the fact is we have documents that prove it and Betas refuse to recognize them.

    Brian Heil E’80
    Epsilon Trustee Corporation
    Chi Psi Fraternity
    University of Michigan


  2. James Tobin - 1978, 1986

    Mr. Heil: I’d be glad to see the documents that make Chi Psi’s case for being first. You can send them to me at My sense from the sources is that it all depends on how we define “first.” In the meantime, check Shelby Schurtz, “Greek letter fraternities at the University of Michigan, 1845-1937” (1937). Yours, James Tobin (I speak as a Fiji. We were way, way behind.)


  3. susan wineberg - 1967, 1971, 1975

    The Alpha Chapter of the Ku Klux Klan was organized at UM in 1868 and had a page in the 1867-1868 Palladium. It never appeared again however. But the “n’ word is very prominent in their announcement and perhaps this is why it didn’t appeal to many—or was forced to disband or go underground. I’d add a copy of the page but I don’t see a way to do that.


  4. Marsha zilch - 1967

    AGD. Most,interesting. U of M has come a long way from my time there grad 1966. No female cheer. No female band. No homecoming queen. Looking back women were there to pursue MRS. What an improvement!


Leave a comment: